Analyst price target herding: how same-direction revisions cluster
By Mathew Auto, AnaChart research desk.
Analyst price target herding is the pattern where one analyst changes a target on a stock and others covering it make the same kind of change within days.
We measured it as same-direction revision clustering across 427,719 price target revisions in AnaChart’s records, with data through 1 October 2026. 52.1% of those revisions sit inside a cluster.
A cluster shows timing. It doesn’t show why the analysts moved. Most clusters probably start with the same earnings report or the same piece of news, and the records don’t carry those dates, so nothing on this page says one analyst copied another.
52.1% of 427,719 directional price target revisions sit in a cluster: three or more revisions on the same stock, in the same direction, from at least three different analysts, each within ten days of the one before. Among follow-on revisions, half arrive within seven days of the cluster’s first day, 78.5% within 14 days and 90.4% within 21. Being among the first to publish is a fairly stable habit: lead rates measured before 2022 correlate 0.63 with lead rates from 2022 on. Data through 1 October 2026.
In this post
- How we define a cluster
- How quickly follow-on revisions arrive
- Analysts who are often first
- Analysts who usually arrive later
- Is a lead rate stable?
- More clustering, or more coverage?
- Where clustering is most common
- How much the ten-day rule matters
- How we measured this, and what it can’t tell you
- Frequently asked questions
Key findings
- 427,719price target revisions checked for same-direction clusters
- 60.3%of revisions sat inside a cluster in 2025, up from 21.0% in 2016
- 222,760revisions came inside a cluster
- 233analysts tested to see if a lead rate holds over time
How we define a cluster
We started with every price target revision where AnaChart has the analyst, the date, the old target and the new one, and the two targets differ. After removing 225 duplicate records, that leaves 427,719 revisions. 59.4% are raises and 40.6% are cuts.
Then we sorted them by stock and by direction and chained together revisions that land within ten calendar days of the previous one. A chain counts as a cluster when it holds at least three revisions from at least three different analysts.
The analyst rule stops one person’s two quick revisions from looking like a crowd. It removes very little: without it the clustered share would be 52.6% instead of 52.1%.
On that definition there are 40,222 clusters holding 222,760 revisions. The median cluster has four revisions and spans six days. 31.4% of revisions have no same-direction revision on that stock within ten days on either side.
The largest cluster is on UBER. On 19 December 2023 Justin Patterson raised his target to $70 from $61, and over the next 87 days 31 analysts made 59 upward revisions between them, the last at $92 on 15 March 2024.
A tighter example is META in spring 2023. Jason Helfstein moved from $220 to $235 on 9 March, and 30 analysts made 55 raises over the following 49 days, ending at $300.
Both runs line up with company results and guidance that every analyst on those stocks was reading at the same time.
How quickly follow-on revisions arrive
The 222,760 clustered revisions split into two groups. 84,630 were published on a cluster’s first day and 138,130 came later.
The first-day group is larger than the number of clusters because several analysts often publish on the same opening day, and we count all of them as first.
Follow-on revisions arrive a median seven days after the first day. 15.4% arrive the next day, 51.4% within a week and 78.5% within two weeks. By day 21 the figure is 90.4%. So most of a cluster is in place within two to three weeks.
Later revisions aren’t smaller. The median first-day revision changed the target by 10.0% and the median later one by 11.0%.
Analysts who are often first
For each analyst we counted how often their clustered revisions came on the cluster’s first day. We call that the lead rate, and we only show analysts with at least 150 clustered revisions. There are 466 of them, and the median lead rate is 36.8%.
| Analyst | Clustered revisions | On first day | Lead rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mike Matson | 181 | 129 | 71.3% |
| Matt O’Brien | 218 | 151 | 69.3% |
| David Chiaverini | 165 | 112 | 67.9% |
| James Fish | 302 | 197 | 65.2% |
| James Ricchiuti | 199 | 127 | 63.8% |
| Deane Dray | 424 | 269 | 63.4% |
| Mayank Tandon | 298 | 184 | 61.7% |
| Kevin McVeigh | 179 | 109 | 60.9% |
| Andrew Wittmann | 201 | 122 | 60.7% |
| Mircea Dobre | 176 | 106 | 60.2% |
| Michael Ciarmoli | 156 | 92 | 59.0% |
| Catherine Schulte | 195 | 115 | 59.0% |
Lead rate is the share of an analyst’s clustered revisions published on the cluster’s first day. Ties count as first. Minimum 150 clustered revisions.
Mike Matson published on the first day of 71.3% of his clusters, close to twice the median. Deane Dray stands out on volume, with 424 clustered revisions and a lead rate of 63.4%.
A high lead rate isn’t a quality score. It doesn’t say whether the target was right, and it depends partly on the stocks an analyst covers and when their firm tends to publish.
Analysts who usually arrive later
At the other end are analysts who mostly publish after a cluster has started. Updating after results and management calls is a normal way to work, so this table describes timing and nothing more.
| Analyst | Clustered revisions | Lead rate | Median days after first day |
|---|---|---|---|
| John Freeman | 215 | 11.2% | 10 |
| Ramsey El-Assal | 343 | 12.2% | 5 |
| Mark Lear | 319 | 12.9% | 8 |
| Jason Bazinet | 262 | 16.0% | 8 |
| Lauren Lieberman | 364 | 16.2% | 3 |
| Ryan Todd | 178 | 16.3% | 8 |
| Ken Usdin | 181 | 17.1% | 7 |
| Brian Meredith | 238 | 17.2% | 4 |
Same population of 466 analysts. Median days is measured across all of the analyst’s clustered revisions.
John Freeman was first in 11.2% of his clusters and typically published ten days after the opening day. Lauren Lieberman has a low lead rate but a median gap of three days, so she’s rarely first and rarely far behind.
Is a lead rate stable?
To check whether lead rates are just noise, we split each analyst’s record at the end of 2021 and kept the 233 analysts with at least 60 clustered revisions on each side.
Lead rate before 2022 correlates 0.63 with lead rate from 2022 on. The quarter of analysts with the highest early rates averaged 53.1% before 2022 and 43.9% after. The lowest quarter averaged 26.8% and then 30.4%. Both groups moved toward the middle, and a gap of 13.5 points remained.
So publishing early is a fairly consistent habit for some analysts. The test shows the measure is stable. It can’t show where that habit comes from, and coverage mix and firm publishing schedules could explain a good part of it.
Key takeaway: some analysts are often first, and the pattern partly holds across years.
More clustering, or more coverage?
Across all stocks, the share of revisions inside a cluster rose from 21.0% in 2016 to 60.3% in 2025. Read on its own, that looks like a sharp rise in herding.
Most of it comes from coverage. The records hold far more revisions in later years, 9,012 in 2016 against 61,222 in 2025, and stocks with many analysts form clusters more easily.
The solid line keeps coverage roughly constant by looking only at stocks with 26 to 50 directional revisions in that year. It moves between 68.9% and 76.0% across the decade, and the 2025 figure is lower than 2016.
On a phone, swipe the table sideways to see every column.
| Revisions on the stock that year | Clustered 2016 | Stocks 2016 | Clustered 2025 | Stocks 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 to 10 | 8.0% | 2,318 | 13.6% | 2,118 |
| 11 to 25 | 47.0% | 127 | 45.0% | 822 |
| 26 to 50 | 75.9% | 17 | 69.8% | 585 |
| 51 to 100 | 75.2% | 2 | 83.0% | 232 |
| 101 or more | none | 0 | 94.3% | 16 |
Clustered share of directional revisions, by how many revisions the stock had in that year. No stock had more than 100 in 2016.
The sample sizes matter here. In 2016 only 17 stocks had 26 to 50 revisions, and only two had 51 to 100, so the early figures in those rows rest on few stocks.
The row with plenty of stocks at both ends is the thinly covered one: stocks with ten or fewer revisions in a year went from 8.0% to 13.6%.
Key takeaway: clustering describes timing. It doesn’t show that analysts copy each other.
Where clustering is most common
Among stocks with at least 300 directional revisions, the highest clustered shares are on large, heavily covered technology names.
| Stock | Directional revisions | Share in a cluster |
|---|---|---|
| CRWDCrowdStrike | 804 | 92.5% |
| METAMeta Platforms | 1,415 | 91.5% |
| SNOWSnowflake | 615 | 90.9% |
| ZSZscaler | 657 | 90.9% |
| CRMSalesforce | 895 | 90.2% |
| NVDANvidia | 1,125 | 90.0% |
| MDBMongoDB | 562 | 89.5% |
| DASHDoorDash | 405 | 89.4% |
Minimum 300 directional revisions.
On CRWD, 92.5% of price target revisions arrived as part of a cluster. For stocks like these, a single revision will usually be followed by others in the same direction within a couple of weeks.
How much the ten-day rule matters
The ten-day gap is a choice, and the clustered share depends on it. A shorter gap gives smaller clusters and a longer one joins more revisions together.
| Gap allowed between revisions | Share in a cluster | Share with no neighbour |
|---|---|---|
| 5 days | 43.3% | 39.9% |
| 7 days | 48.2% | 35.2% |
| 10 days | 52.1% | 31.4% |
| 14 days | 56.7% | 27.5% |
| 21 days | 62.5% | 22.8% |
Cluster means 3 or more revisions from 3 or more analysts. Ten days is the rule used on this page.
Between five and 21 days, the share of revisions in a cluster runs from 43.3% to 62.5%. The pattern holds across that range, and the exact headline figure is a product of the ten-day choice.
Every AnaChart analyst page shows the full history of targets and rating changes with dates. Start with the analyst directory, or open a stock such as AAPL to see the order analysts revised in. Teams that need the underlying records can license them through anachart.store.
How we measured this, and what it can’t tell you
Population. Every recorded price target revision in AnaChart’s data through 1 October 2026 with an analyst, a date, a prior target and a new target, where the two differ.
Exact duplicates were removed. Spelling variants of one analyst’s name are merged, so a person who changes firm keeps one record.
Clusters. Built per stock and per direction. Revisions are sorted by date, and a new chain starts when the gap to the previous revision is more than ten calendar days.
A chain counts as a cluster with at least three revisions from at least three analysts. Because chains are built link by link, a cluster can last longer than ten days in total.
Lead rate. The share of an analyst’s clustered revisions published on the cluster’s first day. Ties on that day all count as first.
Coverage bands. Each stock is placed in a band by its number of directional revisions in that calendar year.
Limits. The data has no earnings dates or news timestamps, so it can’t separate analysts reacting to each other from analysts reacting to the same event.
Lead rate is affected by sector, coverage mix and firm publishing schedules. The ten-day rule changes the headline share, as the table above shows. This page takes no view on any stock or analyst.
Related reading: price targets tend to follow the stock, and how long analysts stay on a stock.
Mathew Auto is the byline of AnaChart’s research desk. Articles under this name are written by the AnaChart team from AnaChart’s record of 660K+ analyst price targets and 750K+ ratings, and every figure is checked against that record before it’s published.
Frequently asked questions
What is analyst price target herding?
It’s the pattern where one analyst’s price target change on a stock is followed within days by same-direction changes from other analysts.
In AnaChart’s records, 52.1% of 427,719 directional revisions sit in a cluster of at least three revisions from three different analysts, each within ten days of the one before.
How fast do other analysts follow a price target change?
Follow-on revisions arrive a median seven days after a cluster’s first day. 51.4% arrive within a week, 78.5% within two weeks and 90.4% within three.
Does clustering mean analysts copy each other?
Not on this evidence. The records don’t include earnings dates or news timestamps, and many analysts revising after the same quarterly report would produce the same pattern. The study measures timing only.
Which analysts are most often first?
Among the 466 analysts with at least 150 clustered revisions, Mike Matson published on a cluster’s first day 71.3% of the time and Matt O’Brien 69.3%. The median for the group is 36.8%.
Has price target herding increased over time?
The share across all stocks rose from 21.0% in 2016 to 60.3% in 2025, mostly because the records cover many more heavily followed stocks.
For stocks with 26 to 50 revisions a year, the share was 75.9% in 2016 and 69.8% in 2025, although the 2016 figure rests on 17 stocks.
Data through 1 October 2026. First published 30 July 2026, revised 5 October 2026 after an outside review: re-run on current data, distinct-analyst rule, full coverage bands with sample sizes, ten-day sensitivity and causal language removed.