How accurate are analyst initiations? We tested 64,090 first calls
By Mathew Auto, AnaChart research desk. Published 19 November 2026. Data through 30 October 2026.
When an analyst starts covering a stock, the first price target gets the attention. It comes with a full report, a fresh rating and usually a headline. We wanted to know whether that first call is any better or worse than the calls that come after it.
So we took 64,090 initiations in AnaChart’s records, from 2010 to October 2025, and checked how many of their targets the stock reached within twelve months. Then we did the same for 418,087 later calls.
First calls did a little worse. The reason is more interesting than the gap.
In this post
First calls against later calls
An initiation here is the first price target a given analyst set on a given stock in our records. Every target after that, by the same analyst on the same stock, counts as a later call. We kept only targets set above the share price, since those are the ones that need the stock to rise.
Across all of them, 59.3% of targets were reached within twelve months. Initiations came in at 55.8% and later calls at 59.8%, a gap of four points.
The gap was there in 15 of the 16 years; 2012 was the exception. Since 2020 it was a bit wider: 54.3% against 59.7%.
When an initiation did get there, it got there slightly faster, in a median 77 days against 82. Our study of how long targets take to be reached has the full timing picture.
First calls aim higher
A new Buy rating usually comes with a big target. In our records the median initiation with a Buy sat 26.1% above the price, against 22.6% for a later Buy. A third of initiations aimed more than 30% higher; for later calls it was 28%.
Bigger targets are harder to reach, so we compared first and later calls at the same distance from the price.
At the same upside the gap mostly closes. Up to 30% above the price, initiations trailed by about two points. Past 30%, there was no difference at all.
So a good part of the four-point gap is simply ambition. First calls ask more of the stock.
The analysts who stay, and the ones who don’t
The rest of the gap shows up when you look at what the analyst did next.
We sorted initiations made up to October 2024 by how many calls the same analyst went on to make on that stock, counting everything through October 2026.
Where the analyst made four or more calls on the stock, 58.9% of first targets were reached, close to the 59.8% for later calls. Where the initiation was the only call they ever made on it, 50.1% were reached. There were 10,773 of those one-off initiations.
We can’t tell from the records why coverage stopped. Analysts move firms, firms drop coverage, and some stocks get taken over. What the numbers do say is that the first call from an analyst who sticks with a stock was about as reliable as any other call they made.
Among analysts with at least three later calls on the same stock, the first call was reached 59.9% of the time and the later ones 59.1%.
Initiations at the biggest firms
We looked at the ten firms with the most initiations in our records. Nine of them had a lower reach rate on first calls than on later ones. Across the 58 firms with at least 200 initiations, 51 did.
| Firm | Initiations | First calls reached | Later calls reached |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jefferies | 2,605 | 56.0% | 58.9% |
| BofA | 2,414 | 58.0% | 64.6% |
| JPMorgan | 2,323 | 60.3% | 64.3% |
| Goldman Sachs | 2,301 | 62.0% | 63.5% |
| Stifel | 2,262 | 58.6% | 61.4% |
| Citi | 2,184 | 59.7% | 63.1% |
| Piper Sandler | 2,158 | 58.0% | 57.8% |
| Morgan Stanley | 2,135 | 58.9% | 63.7% |
| UBS | 1,981 | 62.1% | 65.0% |
| Barclays | 1,864 | 61.7% | 64.1% |
On a phone, swipe the table sideways to see every column.
BofA had the widest gap of the ten, 6.6 points. Piper Sandler was the one firm where first calls did as well as later ones. For how the firms rank on all of their calls, see our most accurate Wall Street firms study.
Five initiations and what followed
Averages hide the calls people remember. Here are five Buy initiations on well-known stocks, and how each one played out.
Fadi Chamoun on XPO (BMO), April 2023. He started coverage on 6 April with a $44 target, 46% above the $30.13 close. XPO got there in 15 days. Chamoun went on to make 19 calls on the stock, and by our 12-month measure 13 of his 14 later targets were reached.
Michael Turrin on Snowflake (Wells Fargo), January 2023. A $170 target on 6 January, 37% above the price. Reached in 27 days. He stayed on the stock for 21 calls, and 17 of his 19 later targets were reached within a year.
Shaun Kelley on DraftKings (BofA), October 2023. $38 against a $26.92 close on 30 October, 41% upside. The stock got there in 18 days. Kelley’s later DraftKings calls were a mixed bag: 4 of 6 reached.
Brad Erickson on Meta (RBC), September 2021. A $425 target with the stock at $339.39, 25% higher. A year later Meta was far below it. The target was finally reached about 28 months after the call, in early 2024. Erickson kept covering Meta for 36 calls, and 20 of his 28 later targets were reached on time.
Andrew Boone on Uber (JMP), November 2021. $80 against $45.51, 76% upside. Uber went the other way first. The stock reached $80 in February 2024, 27 months after the call. Boone stayed with it, and 17 of his 19 later targets were reached within a year.
Three fast hits and two that took more than two years. Meta and Uber show the pattern in the numbers above: an ambitious first call that missed its year, followed by an analyst who stayed and did well afterwards.
How to read the next initiation you see
Look at how far the target sits above the price. A first call 40% or 50% above the price is a long shot whoever makes it, and in our records it was reached no more often than a later call at the same distance.
Then look at the analyst’s record on stocks they have stayed with. That tells you more than the initiation itself. The analyst pages on AnaChart show how often their past targets were reached and how long it took; the accuracy explainer covers how to read those numbers.
How we measured this
Data. AnaChart’s price target records, newest record 30 October 2026. We scored 482,177 targets set above the share price between 1 January 2010 and 30 October 2025, so each had a full twelve months to play out.
Initiation. The first price target in our records from a given analyst on a given stock. Pairs whose first record is before 2010 are counted, but their first scored call is not treated as an initiation, since earlier coverage may exist.
Reached. The stock closed at or above the target within 365 days of the call. Prices are split adjusted and do not include dividends. Upside is capped at 300% when we take medians.
Stayed or not. For the section on analysts who stay, we used initiations made up to 30 October 2024 and counted every call the analyst made on that stock through 30 October 2026.
What this is not. This study uses a simple 12-month reach rate. AnaChart’s performance score, which ranks analysts on the site, also weighs how big the call was and how fast it got there.
Cite this. AnaChart, “How accurate are analyst initiations? We tested 64,090 first calls”, 19 November 2026, anachart.com/analyst-initiation-accuracy/.
Frequently asked questions
What is an analyst initiation?
It is the first time an analyst publishes a rating and price target on a stock. In AnaChart’s records we treat the first price target from a given analyst on a given stock as the initiation.
Are analyst initiations more accurate than later calls?
No, slightly less. 55.8% of initiation targets were reached within twelve months, against 59.8% of later calls, across 64,090 initiations from 2010 to 2025.
Why are first calls less accurate?
Mostly because they aim higher, and many are never followed up. At the same distance above the price the gap is about two points or less, and when the analyst kept covering the stock, 58.9% of first targets were reached.
How often are initiation targets with big upside reached?
Initiations set more than 50% above the price were reached within a year 22.9% of the time, about the same as later calls with that much upside (23.0%).
Which firm’s initiations do best?
Among the ten firms with the most initiations, UBS (62.1%), Goldman Sachs (62.0%) and Barclays (61.7%) had the highest share of first targets reached within a year.
Revision note: first published 19 November 2026 with data through 30 October 2026.