SIGI - Selective Insurance Group - Stock Forecast

Financial Services - Sector
Coverage Stock analysts Price Targets & Ratings Chart Insider Trading

SIGI is currently covered by 4 analysts with an average price target of $84.12. This is a potential upside of $7.71 (10.09%) from yesterday's end of day stock price of $76.41.

Selective Insurance Group's activity chart (see below) currently has 113 price targets and 86 ratings on display. The stock rating distribution of SIGI is 61.54% HOLD, 15.38% BUY and 23.08% SELL.

Stock Analyst Price Targets - Review

Analysts average stock forecasts to be materialized ratio is 76.06% with an average time for these price targets to be met of 132.4 days.

Highest price target for SIGI is $88, Lowest price target is $72, average price target is $81.75.

Most recent stock forecast was given by PAUL NEWSOME from PIPER SANDLER on 02-Feb-2026. First documented stock forecast 11-Jul-2008.

Currently out of the existing stock ratings of SIGI, 8 are a HOLD (61.54%), 2 are a BUY (15.38%), 3 are a SELL (23.08%).

Analyst name

Rating

Current price target

Potential Upside

Previous price target

Date of last PT

Price targets met ratio

Average potential upside

Average Days to Hit Target

Performance score

Hold Since 23-Jan-2017

$86

$9.59 (12.55%)

$79

1 months 12 days ago
(02-Feb-2026)

8/12 (66.67%)

$1.77 (2.10%)

65

Hold Since 07-Feb-2025

$81

$4.59 (6.01%)

$82

2 months 8 days ago
(06-Jan-2026)

6/12 (50%)

$-2.8 (-3.34%)

116

Sell Since 05-Aug-2025

$72

$-4.41 (-5.77%)

$73

3 months 25 days ago
(17-Nov-2025)

3/9 (33.33%)

$-5.38 (-6.95%)

80

Buy Since 30-Oct-2024

$88

$11.59 (15.17%)

$96

7 months 9 days ago
(05-Aug-2025)

9/12 (75%)

$11.17 (14.54%)

121

Sell Since 18-May-2023

$102

$25.59 (33.49%)

$96

1 years 4 months 20 days ago
(22-Oct-2024)

8/9 (88.89%)

$11.26 (12.41%)

90

Show more analysts

Please expand the browser size to see the chart

What is SIGI (Selective Insurance Group) average time for price targets to be met?

On average it took 132.4 days on average for the stock forecasts to be realized with a an average price target met ratio 76.06

Which analyst has the current highest performing score on SIGI (Selective Insurance Group) with a proven track record?

MATTHEW CARLETTI

Which analyst has the most public recommendations on SIGI (Selective Insurance Group)?

Matthew Carletti works at JMP and has 4 price targets and 6 ratings on SIGI

Which analyst is the currently most bullish on SIGI (Selective Insurance Group)?

Grace Carter with highest potential upside - $25.59

Which analyst is the currently most reserved on SIGI (Selective Insurance Group)?

Bob Huang with lowest potential downside - -$4.41

To continue looking at which analysts cover the stock please register to the basic or advanced membership

What is AnaChart?